DeFi & FinTech

S&P Keeps USDT at Weakest Score as Tether Disputes Risks

S&P kept USDT’s stability score at 5 as riskier holdings rose, while Tether defended its reserves and a reported $7.95 billion surplus.

S&P Keeps USDT at Weakest Score as Tether Disputes Risks
S&P kept USDT at its weakest stability score as Tether defended its reserves and reported surplus. Image: Tether

Key Notes

  • S&P kept USDT at 5, the weakest stability score, warning that a fall in the value of higher-risk reserves could erode its backing.
  • Higher-risk holdings equaled 28% of circulating USDT at September 30, while Tether reported a $7.95 billion surplus over total liabilities.
  • Tether disputes S&P’s assessment framework, and the latest review leaves the score unchanged from November 2025.

S&P Global Ratings kept Tether’s USDT at 5, the weakest score on its stablecoin stability scale, warning that riskier reserves could threaten backing during a downturn.

The November 18 review, reported by Cointelegraph, leaves the assessment unchanged from November 2025. Tether disputed the analysis, directing its criticism at S&P’s framework.

The score evaluates a stablecoin’s ability to maintain its peg. S&P’s assessment framework runs from 1, or very strong, to 5, or weak. It considers reserve quality alongside governance, redemption arrangements, technology and track record, rather than assigning a conventional credit rating.

Riskier Holdings Rise Relative to USDT Supply

Higher-risk assets were equivalent to 28% of USDT in circulation at September 30, compared with 24% a year earlier. They included gold, Bitcoin, equities, secured loans and corporate bonds.

S&P warned that falling asset values could leave USDT undercollateralized, while acknowledging its recent record of price stability.

Gold has become an important part of Tether’s investment strategy. MarketSpeaker examined that expansion in January, when the company’s bullion accumulation was already attracting attention beyond the cryptocurrency market.

Tether Points to Its Reserve Cushion

Tether’s October 30 disclosure reported $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities at September 30. The resulting $7.95 billion surplus was almost twice the $4.1 billion reported at the end of June.

The accompanying reserve report lists $139.58 billion in cash, cash equivalents and other short-term deposits. Separate holdings include $19.08 billion in precious metals, $8.37 billion in Bitcoin, $14.18 billion in secured loans and $4.18 billion in public equities.

Calculated from the reported totals, the surplus equaled about 4.3% of liabilities. That is a balance-sheet cushion at the reporting date, rather than a measure of cash immediately available under every market condition. CoinScreamer’s earlier reserve coverage explains the distinction between that buffer and Tether’s operating profit.

Audit Completion and Public Disclosure Remain Separate

Tether announced in August that KPMG US issued an unqualified opinion on Tether International’s 2025 financial statements. The company said the audit examined transactions, valuations, counterparties and supporting evidence across its financial statements.

S&P nevertheless cited unpublished audited statements and unnamed reserve custodians and counterparties as obstacles to checking the information, according to the November report.

BDO’s quarterly assurance addresses a different scope. Its September opinion applies to that reporting date, and explicitly says it provides no assurance for other dates. It also notes that asset valuations assume normal trading conditions rather than extraordinary market disruption.

In its response to Cointelegraph, Tether said the problem lay with S&P’s framework, not its reserves, and invoked The Big Short.

The disagreement follows CEO Paolo Ardoino’s rejection of the 2025 downgrade. His earlier criticism concerns that prior review, rather than a new change in USDT’s score.

Disclaimer: CoinScreamer is an independent media brand owned and operated by NuvexMedia LLC, publishing news, research, and market insights on digital assets and related technologies. NuvexMedia LLC invests in and collaborates with companies across the digital asset, blockchain, and technology sectors. These relationships do not influence CoinScreamer’s editorial coverage, and the publication maintains full editorial independence to provide accurate, timely, and objective information. © 2025 NuvexMedia LLC. All rights reserved. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, investment, financial, or other professional advice.

DeFi & FinTech, Markets & Trading, News, Regulation & Policy